There is so much misinformation surrounding the case of Giovanna Hernandez Martinez, the 24-year-old purported social worker from Leeds who was pulled over for reckless driving and wound up detained at an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) site.
Martinez’s friends and family are advocating for her release. As 1819 News reported, Birmingham Indivisible and Alabama 50501 organized a protest on Sunday in front of a Birmingham church, but a paltry number showed up.
So, is this ICE targeting brown people without cause, or ICE derangement syndrome? What exactly is the deal with this young woman who was in the country illegally for 17 years but never managed to correct her status?
According to accounts, the only identification Martinez had on her when pulled over was one issued in Mexico. That’s curious. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) confirmed on X that Martinez “was tailgating a law enforcement vehicle, passed them erratically at 80 MPH, and cut them off. Upon witnessing this reckless driving, ICE and local police initiated a traffic stop and discovered she was an illegal alien from Mexico.”
Martinez has since been moved to Richwood Correctional Center in Louisiana pending a deportation hearing.
Light on facts and heavy on narrative, the Reuters article is what cemented the “Young Alabama Social Worker” fiction.
Hernandez's parents brought her to the U.S. from Mexico at age 7, her brother said. She was valedictorian of her high school class, has bachelor's and master's degrees in social work, and works with young people applying for college through a local non-profit organization….
A young woman who became a valedictorian, obtained a bachelor’s and a master’s degree, and managed to succeed in the shadows for 17 years should have had the wherewithal to sort out her illegal status. Why didn’t she?
Some media reports also noted that in light of the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, Martinez's family had recently made moves to sort out their illegal status. Why didn’t she act before, when immigration enforcement was far less stringent?
Reuters reached out to the Leeds Police Department and the Pickens County Jail requesting comment, but they did not respond to them. Instead, the Leeds Police Department chose to post the video of Martinez driving recklessly and her subsequent traffic stop on their Facebook page.
WATCH:
The circumstances which got Martinez in hot water appear valid. The fact is, she broke several laws, first by remaining in the country illegally without correcting her status after adulthood; second, by operating a vehicle without a valid driver’s license, adding insult to injury by driving recklessly.
Yes, these multiple violations could have been better investigated. Yet practically every legacy news outlet is trying to spin Martinez into an innocent who did nothing wrong but be an immigrant. They also tried to spin Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the apparent MS-13 gang member and illegal alien who was detained by ICE in Maryland as “Maryland Dad.” He turned out to be a human trafficker and accused domestic abuser. All that glitters is not gold.
Finally, there is the matter of Martinez being referred to as a “social worker.” The legacy media has used the term freely and loosely, but evidence shows otherwise.
Martinez’s LinkedIn profile verifies she graduated with a BSW and MSW in social work from Jacksonville State University, but there is no evidence that Martinez is licensed in the state of Alabama to do social work. The Board of Social Work Examiners of Alabama lists every licensed social worker in the state and considers itself the primary source to verify whether a social worker in Alabama is licensed. One can even download the entire roster of licensed social workers within the state.
Using the roster and searching for “Giovanna,” “Martinez,” “Hernandez-Martinez,” and “Hernandez” did not render any matches with Giovanna Hernandez Martinez. While MSWs and LSWs with a portion of those nomenclatures appeared in the search, no person with Martinez’s full or partial name appeared.
This has not stopped many news agencies from granting Martinez that title. The most accurate documentation was done by WBRC6 News. They revealed that Martinez worked with a pro-illegal organization called the Hispanic Immigration Coalition of Alabama (HICA).
For years, Giovanna Hernandez has worked to help immigrants navigate the complex path of staying in the United States.
As a social worker with the Hispanic Immigration Coalition of Alabama (HICA), her mission has been to protect others from the devastating reality of deportation.
So, Martinez’s “social work” was helping fellow illegals skirt U.S. law and avoid deportation? She avoided it herself for 17 years, so she would know. In this same report, her brother Dilan Hernandez said that HICA had given up on Martinez’ case.
Adding to the family’s heartbreak is disappointment in the organization where Giovanna has worked for the past year.
‘When everything happened, they actually reached out to my mom on the first day and they were like don’t worry about any of the legal fees and everything. We’re already sending lawyers basically to help Giovanna. After not even trying to do a lot for her they told her to go ahead and sign her deportation papers so she could be sent back to Mexico and they told her that’s the best chance and then after two years she would be eligible to apply for a visa,’ Dilan said.
It seems an organization that is expert at making end-runs around immigration law understands when they are beat and there is much more to Martinez’s case than what is being divulged. Whatever that additional intel might be, it adds up to her exit from the U.S. one way or another.
Alireza Doroudi, the University of Alabama doctoral student whose F-1 visa was revoked in March, was placed in ICE detention and chose to self-deport back to Iran. Perhaps Martinez will make that same choice before it is made for her.
Jennifer Oliver O'Connell, As the Girl Turns, is an investigative journalist, author, opinion analyst, and contributor to 1819 News, Redstate, and other publications. Jennifer writes on Politics and Pop Culture, with occasional detours into Reinvention, Yoga, and Food. You can read more about Jennifer's world at her As the Girl Turns website. You can also follow her on Facebook, Twitter, and Telegram.
The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the policy or position of 1819 News. To comment, please send an email with your name and contact information to [email protected].
Don’t miss out! Subscribe to our newsletter and get our top stories every weekday morning.
